Followers

Saturday, June 16, 2012


Does Health Care in America Affect the Comparative Advantage?

 Comparative advantage: the ability of a nation or a country to produce particular goods or services which it is relatively more efficient with a lower opportunity cost over another. Although one country has more efficiently in the production of all goods (absolute advantage) than another, both countries still gain by trading with each other, as long as they have different relative efficiencies.

Detroit’s Big Three (GM, Ford, and Chrysler) U.S automakers have been decreased from 70 percent in 1999 to only 52 percent in 2009 because of increasing competition from foreign automakers, labor costs, economic recession, and decreasing consumer’s demand for new vehicles. However, one of the biggest reasons is health care cost.

In 2008, GM has spent about $4.8 billion on health care that it led to increase the cost of every vehicle. It produced by about $1,500 per vehicle. Furthermore, GM had about 497,000 retired workers and 96,000 active U.S employees. So, GM Company provided health care for one million people. Although Ford and Chrysler paid less than GM for health care, they were in the same ballpark. 

On the other hand, Japanese competitors (Toyota and Honda) spent on their health care costs only about $200 per vehicle, because they provided health care coverage for substantially fewer employees in U.S than the Big Three. They produced by about $1,300 per vehicle.  It is much different of production price of trading, because price depends on production possibilities. As a result, the Big Three’s money could not cause to flow into features that made vehicles more competitive, because the health care increased price of the Big Three’s cars. 

In addition, wage of workers in Big Three was higher than Toyota and Honda. The wage of workers in Big Three averaged $30 per hour. In contrast, it averaged $24 per hour at Toyota and Honda’s factories in U.S. Therefore, the productivity advantages of Big Three were not widely view as the more efficient producers than Japanese competitors.

According to the U.S Chamber of Commerce, at 12 percent, health care is the most expensive benefit paid by U.S employers. Also, The United States spent more than 17 percent of its GDP on health care that is higher than another developed nation. That is a reason why most companies in U.S (telecommunication, education, finance, automobiles, and so on) are concerning about the health care cost. Consumers decide what they want to buy, based on their budget and cost of products. For these reasons, it is eventually that health care can put them at an extensive competitive disadvantage in the international marketplace.

Moreover, health care can affect an ability of Startup Company to find the best workers, disincentive for businesses to grow, and reduce American productivity. While The University of Southern California’s Neeraj Sood said in 2011 CFR roundup, the law provided a number of incentive to improve cost. Firstly, reform established health insurance exchanges that promote greater competition among insurers by making it easier for individuals and small businesses to shop for insurance. Secondly, it imposes an erase tax on generous health insurance plans, one of the primary drivers of rising healthcare costs. Finally, comparative usefulness research and innovative repayment and delivery schemes to improve efficiency in health care. Thus these three factors will provide a powerful force for cost-cutting, which will help make U.S. companies more competitive in the world.